Is Emery Giving Into His Players’ Demands?

With wins over PFC Ludogorets Razgrad and FC Girondins de Bordeaux in the UEFA Champions League and Ligue 1 respectively, Paris Saint-Germain have rallied to calm the nerves of supporters as they head into the international break.

The reigning French champions have struggled since the start of the season to string together any kind of decent run and currently sit in third place in the league—four points off Mario Balotelli’s OGC Nice. However, a similar trend from the last two wins, which saw Unai Emery apparently revert to a similar style of play seen under former manager Laurent Blanc, has been a major talking point.

The Spaniard’s selection of Blaise Matuidi, Thiago Motta, and Marco Verratti in the midfield for the Ludogorets and Bordeaux match mirrored the major component of Blanc’s system as Emery’s PSG looked to be settled on a much calmer possession-based approach. While the play wasn’t as smooth in the Ludogorets match, it was a beauty to watch against Bordeaux over the weekend as PSG dominated every facet over the 90 minutes in front of the Ultras who were allowed to return to the stadium after a long hiatus. In my opinion, it was the most beautiful game Les Parisiens played all season—although that 4-1 thrashing over Olympique Lyonnais in the Trophée des Champions was pretty good too.

As good as PSG have looked as of late, rumors suggest that Emery’s decision to implement the change in style was at the request of some of the key players in the squad. This reportedly coming after the annoying 2-0 loss in Toulouse—their second of the early season—so it’s not totally unreasonable to believe that such an event occurred. This all goes back to what I mentioned when Emery was signed from Sevilla F.C. In my article, I stated that it was important for the manager not to spring too many changes too fast and to make the transition period easier. Instead, the Spaniard tried to force a faster, attacking brand of football, which worked brilliantly in preseason but less convincing since the start of the season.

While many supporters may not have appreciated Blanc’s style of play, you can’t question his accomplishments domestically and with a bit more luck in terms of injuries, he could have reached the semi-finals of the Champions League. So it makes perfect sense if a few players are displeased with Emery’s change and can point to the lack of results as reason enough to change systems. Emery is wise to give into the requests, even if only temporary, because a great manager isn’t one who tries to impose his own vision of things but one who is ready to adapt to bring the best out of his squad.

It’s true that Blanc’s system had it’s flaws and a change was needed to move the club forward, but if the players lack confidence in the manager’s tactics, there’s no way they buy into what he’s trying to do with the side. The preseason and some occasional solid performances has shown PSG can adapt to the Basque manager’s high-intensity system but like Emery noted, wins are key in building confidence and in the familiar possession-based system, the players seem to be back at their best. Once that confidence is back, it will be easier for Emery to sell his own ideas in a more subtle manner and improve the team at the same time.

If anything, the start to the season has shown that handling a club the size of Paris Saint-Germain and dealing with the attitudes of the players isn’t as easy as it’s made out to be. Transition from one new manager to the other is never easy but finding a way to balance it as well as meeting expectations is key and Emery’s approach in the recent matches is definitely a smart way to go. It promises to be quite an eventful season for the capital club and with Champions League dreams and the return of the Ultras, all we can do is sit back and enjoy the ride.

Subscribe to the PSG Talking podcast (iTunes) (Google Play) and follow us on Twitter @PSGTalk.

Photograph by FRANCK FIFE/AFP/Getty Images

Tags Blaise Matuidi Bordeaux Champions League Ligue 1 Ludogorets Marco Verratti Thiago Motta Unai Emery


  1. There is a societal difference between spain and france, france are not able to tolerate dictatorialness as well as maybe some can in spain. Finess and rapport, you catch more flys with french honey.

  2. It’s clear possession based works best for Ligue 1, however to advance in Europe, tactical variation is needed. Many mistakes made early in the transition from Blanc to Emery, many came from the top, NAK. I completely agree with you that Emery should have focused on high intensity and pressing first, while keeping the possession based system and then once we began to string together the wins and the confidence grew, slowly implement the 4-2-3-1 counter-attacking attacking style he likes so much.

    It seems whenever we have sat back against decent teams and absorbed pressure we conceded. Think Lyon’s only goal in the TDC and Arsenal’s equalizer in UCL. I think PSG should focus on keeping the ball but find a way to merry that with quick transitions once possession is lost and the opposition is in our half. Something Atleti has done brilliantly so far this campaign, as their opponents aren’t simply allowing them to counter-attack, so they have varied their style playing both ways in matches and doing so brilliantly.

    Time will tell for PSG……….

Comments are closed

Follow Us